Orlovx5 wife shared.
Find someone who isn't part of a cult. While it's true that Mormons are not one-dimensional and completely predictable, the odds of a successful relationship, given the OP's description of his girlfriend, are slim.
The standard principles of day game apply. These girls are nervous around non-Mormons.
This happened to me, and it took me forever to get out of the cult. Thought the girl and I had a future, and we did, just not with each other I'll bet there are hundreds of boyfriend converts out there.
We are indeed in two different places.
You should want to keep things new and interesting, as you would in any relationship, while still allowing your date to maintain the standards of her faith.